Integrity Rating · CAR1368
Pine Creek Improved Forest Management Project
Forestry & Land Use · Improved Forest Management · United States
CORSIA-approved programmeBB
58/100
Below investment grade
confidence: high
Dimension breakdown · CCP-aligned
Additionality60 · w22
Over-crediting risk47 · w22
Permanence47 · w20
MRV & methodology rigor66 · w16
Double-counting & registry75 · w12
Co-benefits & safeguards63 · w8
Pro
🔒
AI-analyst due-diligence opinion
An executive read on the rating, anomalies the rubric can’t see, and the diligence questions to put to the developer, generated over the full project record. Available on Pro.
Upgrade to ProPro
🔒
Document review
Reads the project's design, monitoring and verification documents where available, then tests the additionality argument, baseline, and quantification against the methodology, with quotes. Available on Pro.
Upgrade to ProProject documents
- California Coastal Conservancy Staff Recommendation: Pine Creek Tract Acquisition (Project No. 23-021-01), June 1, 2023 — contains detailed description of carbon offset project history, CARB approval,Download →other · hosted copy · 226 KB
- CARB ARB — Notice of Satisfaction for Hoopa Valley Tribe Pine Creek Improved Forest Management Project (listed on CARB website)Download →other · hosted copy
- Coffield et al. (2022), 'Using remote sensing to quantify the additional climate benefits of California forest carbon offset projects,' NCBI PMC9826164 (peer-reviewed analysis of 37 California IFM proDownload →other · hosted copy · 21 KB
- CAR1368 Pine Creek IFM Project Design Document — listed on Climate Action Reserve registry (authentication required; not directly fetched)Download →pdd · hosted copy · 259 KB
- CAFR6368-RP7_OVS_v2-20260626.pdf (Offset Verification Statement, 2025)Download →verification · hosted copy · 496 KB
- CAFR6368-RP6_OVS_v2-20260626.pdf (Offset Verification Statement, 2024)Download →verification · hosted copy · 344 KB
- CAFR6368-RP5_OVS_v2-20260626.pdf (Offset Verification Statement, 2023)Download →verification · hosted copy · 486 KB
- CAFR6368-RP4_OVS_v2-20260626.pdf (Offset Verification Statement, 2022)Download →verification · hosted copy · 343 KB
- CAFR6368-RP3_OVS_v2-20260626.pdf (Offset Verification Statement, 2021)Download →verification · hosted copy · 485 KB
- CAFR6368-RP2_OVS_v2-20260626.pdf (Offset Verification Statement, 2020)Download →verification · hosted copy · 343 KB
- Hupa Pine Creek OPDR RP7 V3.2.2.3 signed.pdf (Offset Project Data Report, 2025)Download →monitoring · hosted copy · 1,484 KB
- Hupa Pine Creek OPDR RP6 V3.2.2.3 signed.pdf (Offset Project Data Report, 2024)Download →monitoring · hosted copy · 1,493 KB
- Hupa Pine Creek OPDR RP5 V3.2.2.3 signed.pdf (Offset Project Data Report, 2023)Download →monitoring · hosted copy · 1,489 KB
- Hupa Pine Creek OPDR RP4 V3.2.2.3 signed.pdf (Offset Project Data Report, 2022)Download →monitoring · hosted copy · 1,485 KB
- Hupa Pine Creek OPDR RP3 V3.2.2.3 signed.pdf (Offset Project Data Report, 2021)Download →monitoring · hosted copy · 1,483 KB
- CARB OPO Change Form v2.pdf (Other, 2024)Open →other · source link
- pc-opdr3_20211008-signed.pdf (Offset Project Data Report, 2021)Download →monitoring · hosted copy · 1,665 KB
- 2018-8-2019-6-PROJ-NOTE-CAR1368.docx (Other, 2019)Open →other · source link
- ARB_NF_PineCreek_OVS_V2-2_102920.pdf (Offset Verification Statement, 2019)Download →verification · hosted copy · 262 KB
- 1-pc_initial-opdr-V3-20201022-signed.pdf (Offset Project Data Report, 2019)Download →monitoring · hosted copy · 37,115 KB
- pc_rp2-opdr-20201020-signed.pdf (Offset Project Data Report, 2020)Download →monitoring · hosted copy · 6,818 KB
- 5-pc-modelling-methodology-V2_20200903.pdf (Project Design Document, 2019)Download →pdd · hosted copy · 633 KB
- 4-pc-inventory-methodology-V2_20200903.pdf (Project Design Document, 2019)Download →pdd · hosted copy · 2,819 KB
- 3-pc-final-baseline-V2_20200903.pdf (Project Design Document, 2019)Download →pdd · hosted copy · 96 KB
- 2-pc-baseline-projections-V2_20200903.pdf (Project Design Document, 2019)Download →pdd · hosted copy · 197 KB
- Exhibit VI_PC Financial feasibility analysis redacted.pdf (Other, 2019)Open →other · source link
- Exhibit V_VandBQuantChangeLog.pdf (Other, 2019)Open →other · source link
- Exhibit IV_InvChangeLog.pdf (Other, 2019)Open →other · source link
- PC_Attachment I and J_20191122.pdf (Other, 2019)Open →other · source link
- pc_pab_20190910.zip (Other, 2019)Open →other · source link
- OPDR_AttachmentA.pdf (Other, 2019)Download →monitoring · hosted copy · 377 KB
- AttachmentE_pab.zip (Physical Boundary Map, 2019)Open →other · source link
- Pine_Creek_Listing_Form-signed-20190705.pdf (Offset Project Listing Information Form, 2019)Download →pdd · hosted copy · 486 KB
- Listing_Attachment F.pdf (Other, 2019)Open →other · source link
- Listing_AttachmentL.pdf (Other, 2019)Open →other · source link
- Listing_AttachmentJ.pdf (Other, 2019)Open →other · source link
- Listing_AttachmentI.pdf (Other, 2019)Open →other · source link
- Listing_AttachmentH.pdf (Other, 2019)Open →other · source link
- Listing_AttachmentG.pdf (Other, 2018)Open →other · source link
- Listing_AttachmentA.pdf (Other, 2019)Open →other · source link
Primary documents located by the document review. Hosted copies are served from CarbonDecode; source links open the original registry or developer page.
Pro
🔒
Satellite & MRV review
Gathers satellite and Earth-observation evidence (Global Forest Watch forest-loss, MethaneSAT/IMEO, published analyses) for the project area and assesses reversal and emissions anomalies, with sources. Available on Pro.
Upgrade to ProScoring rationale · auditable trail
Pro
🔒
Line-by-line scoring rationale
See exactly why each dimension scored as it did, every rule, adjustment, and data point behind the grade. The auditable trail buyers and assurance teams need. Available on Pro.
Upgrade to ProRelated projects
All Improved Forest Management →- BBBFinite Carbon - Ahtna Native Alaskan IFMUnited States
- BBBFinite Carbon - Colville IFMUnited States
- BBBFinite Carbon - Sealaska Native Alaskan IFMUnited States
- CChugach Alaska Forest Carbon ProjectUnited States
- BBBBluesource - Cumberland Mountains Improved Forest Management ProjectUnited States
- CWhite Mountain Apache Tribe Forest Carbon Project IIUnited States