Integrity Rating · VCS1900
Makame Savannah REDD
Forestry & Land Use · REDD+ · Tanzania
CORSIA-approved programmeBB
56/100
Below investment grade
confidence: high
Dimension breakdown · CCP-aligned
Additionality47 · w22
Over-crediting risk35 · w22
Permanence76 · w20
MRV & methodology rigor60 · w16
Double-counting & registry70 · w12
Co-benefits & safeguards65 · w8
Pro
🔒
AI-analyst due-diligence opinion
An executive read on the rating, anomalies the rubric can’t see, and the diligence questions to put to the developer, generated over the full project record. Available on Pro.
Upgrade to ProPro
🔒
Document review
Reads the project's design, monitoring and verification documents where available, then tests the additionality argument, baseline, and quantification against the methodology, with quotes. Available on Pro.
Upgrade to ProProject documents
- Makame Savannah REDD Project Description Document (VCS1900) — FileID 47306Download →pdd · hosted copy · 3 KB
- Makame Savannah REDD Validation/Verification Report (VCS1900) — FileID 48283Download →verification · hosted copy · 3 KB
- West et al. (2023) — 'Action needed to make carbon offsets from tropical forest conservation work for climate change mitigation' (arXiv:2301.03354) — includes VCS1900 synthetic control analysisDownload →other · hosted copy · 5,722 KB
- Orbify Independent Review: Evaluating The Makame Wildlife Management Area (August 2024)Download →other · hosted copy · 158 KB
- ICVCM Case Study: Protecting Valuable Dryland Forests from Destruction in Tanzania — Makame Savannah (December 2025)Download →other · hosted copy · 323 KB
- WBCSD NCS in Action — Makame Savannah Project Factsheet (2024)Download →other · hosted copy · 1,058 KB
- Makame REDD Project_Monitoring2023_Calcs_20250205.xlsxOpen →other · source link
- Makame REDD Project_RP5_Calcs_2025-08-13.xlsxOpen →other · source link
- Makame Risk_validation_verification_25June2020.pdfDownload →verification · hosted copy · 208 KB
- VCS_NPR_REP_1900_4_27_2023_4_26_2024 (2).pdfOpen →other · source link
- VCS_NPRT_score_report_Makame_1900_27042023-26042024_20250811.pdfOpen →other · source link
- VCS-Risk-Report_Makame_Ver2.pdfOpen →other · source link
- 1900_LB.kmlOpen →other · source link
- 1900_PA.kmlOpen →other · source link
- 1900_RRL.kmlOpen →other · source link
- ID_1900_VCS_EXEMPTION_APPROVED_03OCT2024.pdfOpen →other · source link
- Makame_local_language_Swahili_PD_Summary_Sept2020.pdfOpen →other · source link
- Makame Savannah and Ntakata Mountains REDD Project Response.pdfOpen →other · source link
- MAKAME WMA RMZP 2017.pdfOpen →other · source link
- VCS_CCB_V3_PRR_1900_19 MARCH 2024.pdfOpen →other · source link
- Makame_LUP.kmlOpen →other · source link
- Makame REDD project area.kmlOpen →other · source link
- 1900_Project Review Report.pdfOpen →other · source link
- CCB_VCS_V4_PRR_Project 1900_21FEB2025.pdfOpen →other · source link
- R_1900_PRR_2OCT2020.pdfOpen →other · source link
- V1_PRR_1900_13NOV2020.pdfOpen →other · source link
- VCS_CCB_PRR_1900_V_27APR2023_26APR2024.pdfOpen →other · source link
- VCS & CCBA CT Makame signed JA copy.pdfOpen →other · source link
- Issuance Representation_1900_2026-05-07.pdfOpen →other · source link
- Issuance-Representation-Makame-V4.pdfOpen →other · source link
- VCS-Issuance-Representation-v4.1 Makame_14Oct20.pdfOpen →other · source link
- VCS-Issuance-Representation-v4.1 Makame_May2022.pdfOpen →other · source link
- LIST_REP_1900_30042019_ (1).pdfOpen →other · source link
- PP_LIST_REP_PL1900_20APR2019.docxOpen →other · source link
- CCB VCS MR 1900 26042022-25042023_20250128_CLEAN.pdfDownload →monitoring · hosted copy · 2,618 KB
- MAKAME_Monitoring_Report_2022_V6_2024-02-20.pdfDownload →monitoring · hosted copy · 2,459 KB
- MAKAME_Monitoring_Report__21August2020.pdfDownload →monitoring · hosted copy · 3,105 KB
- MAKAME_Monitoring_Report__V3_5Oct2020.pdfDownload →monitoring · hosted copy · 3,008 KB
- MAKAME MR Ver 2 Final.pdfDownload →monitoring · hosted copy · 2,754 KB
- V5_CCB_VCS_2024_MR 1900 27042023-26042024_20260326.pdfDownload →monitoring · hosted copy · 3,901 KB
- PROJ_DESC_PL1900_29AUG2017.pdfDownload →pdd · hosted copy · 25,866 KB
- Makame Validation Deed.pdfOpen →other · source link
- VCS-Registration-Representation-v4.1-MAKAME.pdfOpen →other · source link
- CCB_VCS_REPORT_CCBv3.0_VCSv3.4 MAKAME 24062020.pdfDownload →verification · hosted copy · 1,785 KB
- Makame Validation Deed.pdfDownload →verification · hosted copy · 175 KB
- 21024.51_Makame Savannah 3rd_CCB VCS Ver_Report_V3.0_20240228.pdfDownload →verification · hosted copy · 1,300 KB
- CCB_VCS_Verification_Report_MAKAME 15102020.pdfDownload →verification · hosted copy · 1,638 KB
- CCB VCS VerR 1900 27042022-26042023_V2.pdfDownload →verification · hosted copy · 1,568 KB
- CCB VCS VerR 1900 27042023-26042024.pdfDownload →verification · hosted copy · 2,102 KB
- Verification 2 - Verification Report Final.pdfDownload →verification · hosted copy · 1,844 KB
- 21024.00_Makame_Savannah_VCS_Verification_Representation_FinalV2_20220603.pdfDownload →verification · hosted copy · 173 KB
- 21024.51_Makame_VCS-Verification-Representation_V3.0_20240228.pdfDownload →verification · hosted copy · 161 KB
- 21024.52_Makame_VCS_Verification_Representation_V2.pdfDownload →verification · hosted copy · 129 KB
- VCS-Verification-Representation-v4.1 Makame.pdfDownload →verification · hosted copy · 178 KB
- Verification Representation_1900_2025-10-17.pdfDownload →verification · hosted copy · 77 KB
Primary documents located by the document review. Hosted copies are served from CarbonDecode; source links open the original registry or developer page.
Pro
🔒
Satellite & MRV review
Gathers satellite and Earth-observation evidence (Global Forest Watch forest-loss, MethaneSAT/IMEO, published analyses) for the project area and assesses reversal and emissions anomalies, with sources. Available on Pro.
Upgrade to ProScoring rationale · auditable trail
Pro
🔒
Line-by-line scoring rationale
See exactly why each dimension scored as it did, every rule, adjustment, and data point behind the grade. The auditable trail buyers and assurance teams need. Available on Pro.
Upgrade to Pro